Web-Resol Tudo sobre Limpeza Urbana e Resíduos Sólidos!
Waste incinerators should be classified as waste disposal rather than energy recovery, an advocate general has told the European Court of Justice. If the court rules in favour of the opinion, waste companies could find it tougher to ship waste across Europe for the purpose of incineration.
EDIE reports that Advocate-general Francis Jacobs delivered his opinion on the blocking of a municipal waste shipment by Luxembourg authorities. The waste, intended for an incinerator in France, was being disposed of rather than used for energy recovery, said the authorities, and should therefore be sent to a Luxembourg incinerator under the proximity rule governing waste disposal.
The shipment was described by the waste company as being part of a ‘recovery’ process, but was then reclassified by the Luxembourg authorities as ‘disposal’ on the grounds that the principle of a waste incinerator was to dispose of waste. The European Commission intervened, calling for a clarification on whether the incinerator generated energy and could reclaim it.
The case was taken to the European Court of Justice, where Jacobs recommended that the Court dismiss the Commission’s request for clarification. The advocate general argued that an incineration operation should not fall within the description of energy recovery “unless its objective is the use of waste principally as a fuel” such as incinerators used in cement kilns or manufacturing plants. The Commission was merely seeking clarification on the energy potential of the waste, whereas Jacobs argued that “the definition of a recovery operation is based on the criterion of use and hence of the objective of the operation.”
Jacobs strengthened his argument in a further opinion delivered on a German case regarding waste shipment to a cement factory. “The energy generated by the incineration is to be used in the manufacturing process where it will replace conventional fuel,” said Jacob. “If the waste were not available for a given operation, the factory would still operate using other fuel.” In the Luxembourg case, on the other hand, the waste incinerator was designed solely to deal with waste, and would not otherwise exist.
Artigos Relacionados
Check Also
Waste management poses challenges, but could unlock major environmental and economic gains
Every day, the city of Rio de Janeiro, one of the largest metropolises in the Southern Hemisphere, generates 17,000 tonnes of waste, ranging from large industrial debris to candy wrappers bought innocently at newspaper stands. While this waste presents a serious and urgent environmental challenge, it also fuels an increasingly significant portion of the economy, with benefits extending beyond financial gains. - When we look at developed European countries, many are already recycling between 40% and 50%, with some reaching 60%. From an economic standpoint, both recyclable materials and organic waste hold tremendous value - stated Adalberto Maluf, National Secretary for Environment and Environmental Quality at the Ministry of the Environment (MMA), during the Methane Forum: Climate Emergency Brake, at the Rio Nature and Climate Week. Citing a 2025 report, Maluf mentioned that Brazil literally throws away R$27 billion annually, while municipalities spend significantly more - R$45 billion - managing all this waste, often overlooking the environmental impact or economic potential buried in landfills and dumps. - We spend R$45 billion to collect and dispose of waste in landfills, yet we manage to recycle less than a third of the potential. I believe it will be necessary to review contracts, create performance-based remuneration mechanisms, and pay for both effectively sorted materials and those diverted from landfills - he added. According to the IBGE, 60.5% of Brazilian municipalities adopt some form of selective waste collection, and several initiatives serve as examples of how to manage city waste. In his panel presentation, Bernardo Ornelas, Project Coordinator at the Rio de Janeiro Municipal Urban Cleaning Company (Comlurb), highlighted Ecoparque do Caju, a national benchmark in waste management and recycling. There, received materials are sorted and can be used for biogas production, organic compounds for urban gardens, or human consumption, in the case of still...